← back to the Journal

reading journal ideas: how to remember books by how they made you feel

By Rhea, founder of Trace ·

everyone talks about reading journals, star ratings and reading trackers. this is about something quieter: remembering books by how they made you feel.

i was never really a reader. growing up, my dad, who loves books, always tried to get me to become someone who could enjoy and learn from a good book. i always wanted that too, but it never came to fruition. that is, until 2022, when a very good friend of mine gifted me pachinko.

i never used to read sad books, too afraid of feeling too deeply for characters who would not have to carry the burden of what they evoked in me. but i was hooked. it was the longest book i had ever read, and with every chapter, i sent her voice notes of shock, awe and sadness. and i think that was the first time i realised it wasn't enough to just read a book. it was to recognise what it was saying, to the world and to you.

tomorrow, and tomorrow, and tomorrow, evelyn hugo and a court of splintered harmony, kept by feeling.

the books that stay with you change how you live

i felt this most strongly last year, when i read the invisible life of addie larue by v.e. schwab. in a world where not showing up for others can sometimes be defined as self care, we tend to forget what a privilege it is to be needed, to be loved, to be remembered. it gave me a whole new perspective on life. so every time i got invited to an early breakfast catch-up and all i wanted to do was sleep, i remembered how much i want to be a villager building her village.

books are shaped by the people you read them with

i spent the following years reading all kinds of books, fiction, non-fiction, and co-reading books became how i bonded with the people i love. the idea of staying up messaging each other, theorising about the next chapter, was everything. this year, i even ended up co-reading the firm with my dad, which was very cool. he apparently picked up the plot in the first chapters, and i'd like to believe so did i.

why a reading tracker is not enough

books are not just defined by their authors but also by the people who recommended them to me, who read them with me, discussed them with me. i love a good tracker of data myself, and i'm fiercely protective of my kindle streak. but to me it's not enough just to know the count or the titles of the books i read. i want to remember who i was when i read them, what was going on in my life, what i learnt and how i changed.

that is the gap. a reading tracker can tell you that you read, and how often. it cannot tell you what the reading did to you.

a feeling-first way to remember books

this is why i built trace the way i did. not as another thing to keep up with, but as a quieter place to keep what reading actually leaves behind.

instead of a score, you write one honest line about how a book left you. instead of stars, you choose a worded verdict that sounds like something a real person would say: loved it. stayed with me. glad i read it. you can note who you read it with, what was happening in your life at the time, the chapter that wrecked you. there is no feed, no followers, no performance. just the feeling, kept.

atmosphere by taylor jenkins reid, kept by how it felt, in the app.

reading journal ideas that keep the feeling, not the score

if you have ever searched for reading journal ideas, here is the version i would offer, whatever you choose to keep them in:

  • write one line about how the book left you, not whether it was "good."
  • note who recommended it or read it with you. the people are part of the book.
  • capture what was going on in your life while you read it. you are keeping a record of yourself, not just the book.
  • skip the star rating. use the words you would actually say to a friend.
  • keep the private things private. not every reaction needs an audience.

you can do all of that in a notebook. i just wanted something that held the feeling without turning my reading into a performance, so i made trace do it in a few seconds, on my phone, for me.

some things are just for you

our stories are shaped by those of others, and i don't want to forget any of what has made me myself. and some of that is very private. i don't want to share every anecdote with the world as a review or a comment. some things are just for me.

that is the whole idea. keep the feeling, not the scoreboard, and keep the private things private.

if that is the kind of remembering you want too, you can start your own feeling-first bookshelf on trace for free. traceyourstory.com

and if you keep more than books, the concerts, the trips, the small ordinary days, that is what the rest of trace is for. you can read how we think about it in how to make a digital scrapbook, travel scrapbook ideas, and what to do with digital concert tickets.

faq

why do i forget books right after i read them? usually because you remember that you read it, not how it landed. we hold on to what we feel, so a plot summary or a star rating fades fast, while one honest line about what a book did to you tends to stay.

how do you remember what you read? tie the book to your life, not to a score. note who you read it with, what was going on for you at the time, and the one moment that got you. those hooks bring the whole book back later far better than a rating ever will.

do reading journals actually work? they work when they capture feeling, not admin. the ones that turn into page counts, streaks and star ratings tend to get abandoned. keep it to a sentence about how the book left you and you will actually keep doing it.

how do you keep track of books without star ratings? use words instead of numbers. worded verdicts like "loved it," "stayed with me" or "glad i read it" hold more than five stars ever could, because they sound like how you would actually describe a book to a friend.